| 1972-1973 | ||
| First Team | ||
| Goaltender | Gerry Cheevers | Cleveland Crusaders |
| Defense | J.C. Tremblay | Quebec Nordiques |
| Defense | Paul Shmyr | Cleveland Crusaders |
| Left Wing | Bobby Hull | Winnipeg Jets |
| Center | Andre Lacroix | Philadelphia Blazers |
| Right Wing | Danny Lawson | Philadelphia Blazers |
| Second Team | ||
| Goaltender | Bernie Parent | Philadelphia Blazers |
| Defense | Jim Dorey | New England Whalers |
| Defense | Larry Hornung | Winnipeg Jets |
| Left Wing | Gary Jarrett | Cleveland Crusaders |
| Center | Ron Ward | New York Raiders |
| Right Wing | Tom Webster | New England Whalers |
| Third Team | ||
| Goaltender | Al Smith | New England Whalers |
| Defense | Ted Green | New England Whalers |
| Defense | Rick Ley | New England Whalers |
| Left Wing | Wayne Carleton | Ottawa Nationals |
| Center | Christian Bordeleau | Winnipeg Jets |
| Right Wing | Norm Beaudin | Winnipeg Jets |
| 1973-1974 | ||
| First Team | ||
| Goaltender | Don McLeod | Houston Aeros |
| Defense | Pat Stapleton | Chicago Cougars |
| Defense | Paul Shmyr | Cleveland Crusaders |
| Left Wing | Bobby Hull | Winnipeg Jets |
| Center | Andre Lacroix | New York Golden Blades/Jersey Knights |
| Right Wing | Gordie Howe | Houston Aeros |
| Second Team | ||
| Goaltender | Gerry Cheevers | Cleveland Crusaders |
| Defense | J.C. Tremblay | Quebec Nordiques |
| Defense | Al Hamilton | Edmonton Oilers |
| Left Wing | Mark Howe | Houston Aeros |
| Center | Wayne Carleton | Toronto Toros |
| Right Wing | Mike Walton | Minnesota Fighting Saints |
| 1974-1975 | ||
| First Team | ||
| Goaltender | Ron Grahame | Houston Aeros |
| Defense | J.C. Tremblay | Quebec Nordiques |
| Defense | Kevin Morrison | San Diego Mariners |
| Left Wing | Bobby Hull | Winnipeg Jets |
| Center | Andre Lacroix | San Diego Mariners |
| Right Wing | Gordie Howe | Houston Aeros |
| Second Team | ||
| Goaltender | Gerry Cheevers | Cleveland Crusaders |
| Defense | Poul Popiel | Houston Aeros |
| Defense | Barry Long | Edmonton Oilers |
| Left Wing | Marc Tardif | Quebec Nordiques |
| Center | Serge Bernier | Quebec Nordiques |
| Right Wing | Anders Hedberg | Winnipeg Jets |
| 1975-1976 | ||
| First Team | ||
| Goaltender | Joe Daley | Winnipeg Jets |
| Defense | Paul Shmyr | Cleveland Crusaders |
| Defense | J.C. Tremblay | Quebec Nordiques |
| Left Wing | Marc Tardif | Quebec Nordiques |
| Center | Ulf Nilsson | Winnipeg Jets |
| Right Wing | Anders Hedberg | Winnipeg Jets |
| Second Team | ||
| Goaltender | Ron Grahame | Houston Aeros |
| Defense | Kevin Morrison | San Diego Mariners |
| Defense | Pat Stapleton | Indianapolis Racers |
| Left Wing | Bobby Hull | Winnipeg Jets |
| Center | Robbie Ftorek | Phoenix Roadrunners |
| Right Wing | Real Cloutier | Quebec Nordiques |
| 1976-1977 | ||
| First Team | ||
| Goaltender | John Garrett | Birmingham Bulls |
| Defense | Darryl Maggs | Indianapolis Racers |
| Defense | Ron Plumb | Cincinnati Stingers |
| Left Wing | Marc Tardif | Quebec Nordiques |
| Center | Robbie Ftorek | Phoenix Roadrunners |
| Right Wing | Anders Hedberg | Winnipeg Jets |
| Second Team | ||
| Goaltender | Joe Daley | Winnipeg Jets |
| Defense | Poul Popiel | Houston Aeros |
| Defense | Mark Howe | Houston Aeros |
| Left Wing | Rick Dudley | Cincinnati Stingers |
| Center | Ulf Nilsson | Winnipeg Jets |
| Right Wing | Real Cloutier | Quebec Nordiques |
| 1977-1978 | ||
| First Team | ||
| Goaltender | Al Smith | New England Whalers |
| Defense | Lars-Erik Sjoberg | Winnipeg Jets |
| Defense | Al Hamilton | Edmonton Oilers |
| Left Wing | Marc Tardif | Quebec Nordiques |
| Center | Ulf Nilsson | Winnipeg Jets |
| Right Wing | Anders Hedberg | Winnipeg Jets |
| Second Team | ||
| Goaltender | Ernie Wakely | Houston Aeros |
| Defense | Rick Ley | New England Whalers |
| Defense | Barry Long | Winnipeg Jets |
| Left Wing | Bobby Hull | Winnipeg Jets |
| Center | Robbie Ftorek | Cincinnati Stingers |
| Right Wing | Real Cloutier | Quebec Nordiques |
| 1978-1979 | ||
| First Team | ||
| Goaltender | Dave Dryden | Edmonton Oilers |
| Defense | Rick Ley | New England Whalers |
| Defense | Rob Ramage | Birmingham Bulls |
| Left Wing | Mark Howe | New England Whalers |
| Center | Robbie Ftorek | Cincinnati Stingers |
| Right Wing | Real Cloutier | Quebec Nordiques |
| Second Team | ||
| Goaltender | Richard Brodeur | Quebec Nordiques |
| Defense | Dave Langevin | Edmonton Oilers |
| Defense | Paul Shmyr | Edmonton Oilers |
| Left Wing | Morris Lukowich | Winnipeg Jets |
| Center | Wayne Gretzky | Edmonton Oilers |
| Right Wing | Blair MacDonald | Edmonton Oilers |